Although the US has often prided itself of the status of sole interlocutor in the Middle East “conflict”, it has equally gained the reputation of an interested and biased mediator. In parallel, the European Community or EC – now European Union, EU – claimed to have a ‚more balanced’ approach on the Middle East file, which in turn garnered Palestinians’ trust. But during the current escalation, the EU has been woefully disunited. This blog argues that a more unified European voice can only come about by “walking the talk” of an Israel-Palestine policy/peace agreement based on purported basic European values.
Schlagwort: EU
EU Democracy Support in the Southern Neighborhood: How the EU Contradicts its own Practices
For decades, the EU has declared that it aims to support democratization in its southern neighborhood. Yet, the EU’s cooperation with repressive rulers in other policy fields, such as energy, migration, security, and trade, contradicts the EU’s own democracy support objectives. European policymakers have apparently not learnt from the pre-2011 period. As we argue in our project SHAPEDEM-EU, the EU must embark on a journey of un-, de- and re-learning, and it must avoid contradicting practices in different policy fields. This can be done by introducing a democracy learning loop.
Debating Foreign Interference in a Multipolar World: Is the EU Becoming Illiberal?
The ways in which foreign interference by China, Russia and others are currently discussed in Brussels indicate that the EU is considering moving away from liberal principles in the area of international civil society support and the foreign funding of NGOs in particular. Based on a co-authored comment in the Heidelberg Journal of International Law, this blog post argues that it is helpful to read the current EU debate on foreign interference in the light of the ongoing, conflict-ridden transformation of the global order.
Weltraum in der Nationalen Sicherheitsstrategie
Die Bundesregierung hat am 12. Juni 2023 nach langen Diskussionen ihre Nationale Sicherheitsstrategie verabschiedet. Neben vielen anderen Themen wird darin auch der Weltraum als Gegenstand deutscher Sicherheitspolitik diskutiert. „Die freie und ungehinderte Nutzung des Weltraums ist für unsere Sicherheit unverzichtbar“ (S. 16), heißt es dort. Was folgt daraus für die deutsche Sicherheitspolitik?
Harmonisierung um jeden Preis
Am heutigen Internationalen Flüchtlingstag ist die Situation für Geflüchtete so düster wie wohl seit Einführung des Gedenktages im Jahr 2001 noch nie. Während 2022 mehr als 100 Millionen Menschen auf der Flucht waren, lassen sich weltweit, insbesondere im Globalen Norden, Bestrebungen zur Aushöhlung des Flüchtlingsrechts beobachten. Die EU plant eine umfassende Reform des europäischen Asylrechts, doch auch dieser wird keine Harmonisierung gelingen, da Kernprobleme des bisherigen Systems nicht angegangen werden. Menschenrechtliche und rechtsstaatliche Grundsätze werden zum Bauernopfer.
Der Platz der Ukraine in der europäischen Sicherheitsordnung: Konturen einer Debatte II
Die Diskussion um die Frage, wie sich die Sicherheit der Ukraine nach dem Krieg garantieren ließe, ist voll entbrannt. Wenn sich der Weg in die NATO als nicht gangbar erweisen sollte, welche Alternativen böten sich an und wie sind sie zu bewerten? In dem zweiten Blogbeitrag zu dem Thema geht es um Sicherheitsgarantien durch umfassende militärische Unterstützung, durch die Stationierung westlicher Truppen, durch die Aussicht auf EU-Mitgliedschaft und durch Arrangements, die auch russische Sicherheitsinteressen berücksichtigen.
Decoupling and the “New Cold War”: Cautionary Lessons from the Past
An emerging “new Cold War” appears to pit democracies, led by the US, against autocracies, led by Russia and China. But the analogy between today’s regime competition and that of the “old” Cold War is deceptive. China and Russia today are much more closely intertwined with Western democracies than the Soviet Union ever was. These linkages will complicate the conflict considerably. There is already growing pressure to engage in “decoupling”, that is, to break these interdependencies. Research on past instances of decoupling shows that such processes often exacerbate conflict. This research offers four lessons about the general dynamics of decoupling – and little cause for optimism about today’s disengagement processes.
Why the Future German Arms Export Control Act Goes in the Right Direction—But Not Far Enough
On 13 October 2022, the German Ministry for Economics and Climate published draft key points for a future German Arms Export Control Act (referred to hereafter as ‘the draft’). Establishing such a law is one goal that the government defined in the coalition agreement. The draft contains several good points that can help make German arms export policy more restrictive and more closely aligned with peace, human rights and security policy goals. At the same time, the draft reveals some serious gaps that must be remedied to fully live up to this claim.
Coherent Peace Policy: It’s the Content that Counts
That inter-ministerial competition doesn’t make for more successful foreign policy is a commonplace observation. However, it isn’t enough that all parts of government pull together, they must move together in the right direction.
Responding to Foreign Interference in the EU: Beware of Unintended Consequences
The EU’s emerging response to foreign interference, as it is currently debated in the EU Parliament, contains striking similarities to arguments put forth by some governments around the world seeking to justify harsh restrictions on foreign funding and “foreign agents.” This risks producing serious ramifications for civic spaces and international civil society support—both within and beyond the EU.
